Beyond Poll To Replace The Good Place

79 thoughts on "Beyond Poll To Replace The Good Place"

1. When do we find out which show won the poll?

1. They just posted the schedule today. What We Do in the Shadows won.

2. Damn all of these shows are incredible, this is the best list they’ve ever had for a poll (so say we all).

3. I am absolutely BEGGING for y’all to finally watch Psych

4. For the BSG fans all I have to say is…. SO SAY WE ALLLLL

5. Battlestar Galactica is my all-time comfort watch, so yes please!

   Fringe, Hannibal or Twin Peaks are (twin) peak also.

6. Silo because it’s short, they can be done in like 3 months and watch a new show…

7. Silo for my personal choice. Fringe and Battlestar Galactica next, for Eric & Aaron to finally get what they want 🙂
   Such great shows on the list, can’t go wrong really

8. I feel like I’ve been waiting for years for Fringe to win one of these polls. Let 2026 be the year…🙌

9. Psych! Please let it be that gem of a show

10. Legion was too much for them …. as much as I’d love Twin Peaks I don’t think they’re the target demo.

11. SILOOOOOOO

12. IT HAS TO BE FROM

13. I been waiting for so many years for Fringe, I need Fringe or WWDITS.

14. Twin Peaks is soapy David Lynch goodness. Battlestar Galactica 04 is one of the best Sci-Fi’s of the 21st century. Silo is 2 seasons in and continues to impress.

    Id love to see For All Mankind on a poll soon.

15. WWDITS, The Wire, and Fringe are elite. Silo and From are solid, too.

16. They would love the Last Kingdom and Hannibal, but because both series have been so overlooked over the years they will never win :/

    Then again so was Black Sails and now it seems more popular than ever

17. man psych will always be my number one vote as its my favorite show of all time even though im pretty positive it wont win. i will have hope

18. Someone go ask ChatGPT which show has the most needles. No reason.

19. Psych should take priority over all else. It is one of the best and most consistent shows of all Time and I know Eric would love it.

20. The greatness of the filmmaking and writing of the wire cannot be understated. Only show that’s better for me is the sopranos, and only marginally. Both are equally good picks as objective best shows of all time, but the wire has an edge because it’s a different kind of show, and has something completely different to say. The wire is perhaps the most poignant turn of the century period piece and time capsule show. I think it also has some of the best written characters in film as a whole, and it has so much to say about living in the modern world at the turn of the century, and it only grows more interesting as our modern world continues to evolve and change. The wire is a vignette of a world that once existed, a snapshot of the time during which it was set, and released, and yet to the modern viewer, it grows in relevancy with each passing year, remaining timeless. It’s a story about the tug of war between our notions of what it means to be human, and the bureaucratic nature of our institutions, institutions which are located on either side of the law, and how sometimes those institutions have a toe dipped in both sides.

21. From is my top pick. even though i would love them to react to psych. i know for a fact most of them have already seen that show so I can’t make it my first pick

22. The wire! Just so I have an excuse to watch it again! Lol

23. The wire! Just so I have an excuse to watch it again! Lol

24. FROM!!!! 🙌

25. I really hope The Wire wins this time!

26. For The Love of EVERYTHING. It HAS to be the Wire

27. What We Do In the Shadows hype!!

1. I’m really hoping Psych or What We Do in the Shadows wins! They’re both my favorites, and since they’ve already seen the movies, watching their reactions to the shows would be so fun.

2. I’m really hoping Psych or What We Do in the Shadows wins! They’re both my favorites, and since they’ve already seen the movies, watching their reactions to the shows would be so fun.

28. Please What we do in the Shadows voted for it every chance for years now the guys will love it just like they did the film.

29. FRINGE!!! I need reactions to that one. And in second place, From.

30. HANNIBAL. There has never been a truly good youtube reactor series for this show. BW are the only one I trust to do my favorite show justice.

1. Heyy, I recommend watching IndieGeekGuy reactions to Hannibal, genuinely the best ones I’ve seen lol but the world really needs more good hannibal reactions out there, I hope it wins this time 😓

31. “bears”, “beets”…”Battlestar Galactica”

32. I so want Fringe. Battlestar and The Wire I would be happy with but other reactors I follow have done them. The Last Kingdom I’ve only seen the first 2 seasons and it’s been over 30 years since I saw Twin Peaks

33. There some good options, might as well choose wisely.

34. What we do in the shadows or Twin Peaks are def my main two. Orville or the Ted show could be fun watches in the future, idk how popular they are though.

35. No option for Stargate? Was hoping it might have a chance after the new show announcement

36. The Wire should always be the first option. Then Psych or Fringe.

37. Hannibal better win bruh all these other shows suck

1. I know I been waiting time for them to react to it

38. DEFINITELY What We Do in the Shadows! That show is unbelievably funny, I find it’s a little underappreciated just how funny it is. Plus it’s a relatively short series!

39. I have been voting for Hannibal, Battlestar, and Fringe for 87 years.

40. Hannibal, Battlestar, Psych. Although any on the list makes a fantastic choice.

41. I feel bad for Hannibal fans, but Silo is so good and it’s short too, so another poll would come quick.

1. It has 2 more seasons on the way lol. Hannibal they can easily get done before season 4 is out for Silo.

1. You’re not wrong, Hannibal would be 39 weeks so Silo season 4 would probably be on its way by then. But, I was thinking more so that Silo only has 20 episodes right now, so 20 weeks because we don’t even know if season 3 will come out while they’re watching. I do like your logic though, it gives me a different way at looking at it, so honestly, I am hoping for the Hannibal fans.

42. FROM FROM FROM FROM FROOOOOOOOM

    twin peaks would be cool too

43. I’d love to see Buffy The Vampire Slayer on this list…

1. +1 on that!!

2. I was really hoping that was going to be an option when I watched the poll video.

44. Twin Peaks is the best show in the history of television but it’s not great react material. So much of it is stabbing into your brain deeper than the point where you form normal opinions to talk about stuff.

    Still gave it the 2 pointer, and the 3 pointer goes to the next best TV show you guys haven’t watched yet, The Wire.

45. I know you guys will love From

46. If you do Twin Peaks remember this:

    Season 1
    Season 2
    Fire Walk With Me (Movie)
    Season 3 (The Return)

    That’s the watch order.

1. Cooper, you remind me today of a small Mexican chihuahua!

47. TWIN PEAKS PLEEEAAASEEEEE

48. FROM OR SILO I’m good with either

49. Gotta be The Last Kingdom. Eric is gonna be an emotional mess and it’ll be great! And please try to have all 4 of you reviewing it! Rick and Calvin’s take will be excellent. Thanks!

50. Psych > Hannibal any day.

51. I’m still surprised that you guys haven’t gotten to The Wire yet

52. Please let it be Battlestar for once!

53. no pluribus 💔

54. Really hope 3 Body Problem ends up being picked for voting someday, found it on Netflix recently after a friend recommended it, I’m most of the way thru the first series now it’s renewed for a second one and it’s been a pretty interesting show.

55. Hopefully From gets picked before i die 😭

56. OH YEAH!! “FROM”, Please!! We’re reacting to this as well on our Patreon [we’re on Season 2 now]! It’s so good! I vote “FROM” and THEN “What We Do In The Shadows” [SO FUNNY!!] Fringe is good too! I think you’d enjoy all three, but I would enjoy watching YOU watch these three specifically.

57. Please let it be Hannibal guys, it’s been sitting there for so many years and it’ll be relatively short compared to other series to finish 😭

58. I’ve been voting for Battlestar Galactica for years, simply because I know the guys will love it. If only my vote would count this one time. 😭

59. The Last Kingdom !!

60. I just created an account to vote and when I got signed in, it said I already voted. I did not. I would pick Fringe, From, Psych, in that order.

61. Han.ni.bal! Han.ni.bal! Han.ni.bal! I’m chanting this into winning join me brothers and sisters.

    Also Twin Peaks then Psych.

62. Come on Fringe

1. Is your avatar a reference to RWBY?

63. 1 From
    2 Silo
    3 The Wire

64. 1. What we do in the shadows
    2. Twin Peaks
    3. From

65. Psych!!!!!!

66. The Wire, The Last Kingdom, and Battlestar Galactica are all peak television. I would also recommend For All Mankind on Apple TV
    In an alternate timeline in 1969, Soviet cosmonaut Alexei Leonov becomes the first human to land on the Moon. This outcome devastates morale at NASA but also catalyzes a U.S. effort to catch up. With the Soviet Union emphasizing equality by including a woman in subsequent landings, the United States is forced to match pace, equally training women and ethnic minorities (who historically were largely excluded from the initial decades of U.S. space exploration).

    Pushed by higher competition, the Soviet and other blocs favor more competent leaders, modernizing earlier and on more rational ground. With sustained investments in technology, a broad, sustained, and global technological race takes place, with a wide range of dramatic civilian effects, such as early civil rights, electric vehicles, civilian fusion power, controlled CO2 production, and no climate crisis. Each subsequent season takes place about a decade later, with season two taking place in the 1980s, season three taking place in the 1990s, and season four taking place in the 2000s.

    Ronald D. Moore explained how historical reality had been different from the series: “Sergei Korolev was the father of the Soviet space program; in our reality, he died during an operation in Moscow (in 1966) … And after that point, their Moon program really never pulled together…. Our point of divergence was that Korolev lives, … and he made their Moon landing happen.”[8]

1. I REALLY am hoping For All Mankind makes it on here eventually

2. Okay, I get you really want to see a reaction to this, but maybe it’s a bad idea to spoil major world building for the show before they possibly react to it.